Is it hydrating? Every everyday drink compared
By Gonçalo, founder of Rainu · Updated 16 October 2026 · 7 min read
Short answer: almost every everyday drink hydrates you. In a trial that compared 13 drinks, the body kept sparkling water, tea, coffee, cola, orange juice and a sports drink about as well as still water. Milk was kept even better. The exception is stronger alcohol: wine and spirits make you lose a little extra water.
The quick answer, drink by drink
Every drink here was compared with water in a study cited below, except the ones marked *: those weren't tested on their own, but they are mostly water and a normal serving has nothing in it that makes you lose fluid. The last column is the closest of Rainu's six drink types and how much of the volume counts as water.
| Drink | Hydrating? | In Rainu |
|---|---|---|
| Still water | The reference | Water 100% |
| Sparkling water, seltzer, LaCroix | Yes, same as still water | Water 100% |
| Milk, whole or skimmed | Yes, better than water for a few hours | Milk 88% |
| Tea: black, green, herbal, iced | Yes | Tea 100% |
| Coffee | Yes, in moderate amounts | Coffee 99% |
| Orange juice | Yes | Juice 89% |
| Apple and cranberry juice, lemonade | Yes* | Juice 89% |
| Cola and diet cola | Yes | Soda 89% |
| Sprite, ginger ale, other sodas | Yes* | Soda 89% |
| Sports drinks: Gatorade, Powerade | Yes, same as water at rest | Soda 89% |
| Coconut water | Yes, about like water | Juice 89% |
| Kombucha, lemon water, flavored water | Yes* | Water 100% |
| Regular beer | Neutral in moderation, not a way to hydrate | Not logged |
| Wine and spirits | No, a small extra water loss | Not logged |
Rainu counts what is in the glass: each drink by its typical water content. It doesn't add a bonus for milk, even though your body holds on to milk longer, so its count stays on the cautious side.
How scientists measure it
The best comparison so far is a 2016 trial. 72 men, already well hydrated, drank a litre of a drink over 30 minutes, and researchers collected their urine for the next four hours. From that they built a beverage hydration index: how much water the body still held two hours later, compared with still water (which scores 1.0). The index was corrected for each drink's water content.
Three drinks scored higher than water: skimmed milk (1.58), an oral rehydration solution (1.54) and whole milk (1.50). Cola, diet cola, hot tea, iced tea, coffee, lager, orange juice, sparkling water and a sports drink were no different from still water. Maughan et al., American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2016.
Keep in mind that the index only looks at a few hours after one big drink. Over a whole day, what matters most is how much you drink in total.
Is sparkling water hydrating?
Yes. Sparkling water hydrated exactly like still water in the 2016 trial. The bubbles are carbon dioxide, which doesn't change how much water your body keeps. The same goes for seltzer, club soda and unsweetened flavored sparkling waters such as LaCroix: they are water with bubbles, so they count fully toward your day.
Is sparkling water good for you? Teeth, bones and bloating →
Some people find bubbles fill them up faster. If that's you, sip it through the day rather than drinking a big glass at once.
Tap, spring, purified or mineral: what's the best water to drink? →
Is milk hydrating?
Yes, and in the hours after drinking it, more than water. In the 2016 trial both whole milk (index 1.50) and skimmed milk (1.58) left people holding on to more fluid than still water did. The researchers point to what milk contains: protein, fat, sugar and minerals such as sodium and potassium slow down how quickly the fluid passes through, so less of it ends up as urine.
That doesn't make milk a replacement for water. It has calories, and a glass of water is still the simplest everyday choice. Chocolate milk works the same way with more sugar. Plant milks such as almond or oat weren't tested; they are mostly water too, so they count toward your intake.
Is coconut water hydrating?
Yes, about as hydrating as water. In a 2012 study, 12 trained men exercised until they lost about 2% of their body weight, then drank bottled water, coconut water, coconut water from concentrate or a sports drink on four separate days. All four rehydrated them in a similar way, and their exercise performance afterwards was no different. The men reported feeling more bloated and having more stomach upset with coconut water. Kalman et al., Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, 2012.
So coconut water isn't more hydrating than water. Drink it if you like the taste.
Is tea hydrating?
Yes. In a 2011 trial, 21 men drank either four or six 240 ml mugs of black tea with a splash of milk, or the same amounts of water, over 12 hours. Their blood and urine showed no differences: the tea hydrated like water. Ruxton & Hart, British Journal of Nutrition, 2011. Hot tea and iced tea were also no different from water in the 2016 trial. Does tea dehydrate you? →
- Green tea usually has less caffeine than black tea, so the same applies.
- Herbal tea such as mint, chamomile or rooibos has no caffeine at all. It counts just like water.
- Sweet tea and unsweetened iced tea hydrate the same way; sweet tea just adds sugar.
Is coffee hydrating?
Yes, in moderate amounts. Coffee is about 99% water, and studies of regular coffee drinkers found it hydrates about as well as water. Caffeine only makes you pee more after a large dose, mainly if you aren't used to it. Decaf hydrates like water. The full story is in Does coffee dehydrate you?, and you can add up your day with the caffeine calculator.
Is juice hydrating?
Yes. Orange juice was no different from water in the 2016 trial. Apple juice, cranberry juice and lemonade weren't tested, but they are mostly water as well, so they count toward your day.
The catch is sugar, not hydration: juice is an easy way to drink a lot of sugar without noticing. Count it, but don't rely on it for most of your water.
Is soda hydrating?
Yes. Cola and diet cola were both no different from still water in the 2016 trial, even with their caffeine. Other sodas such as Sprite or ginger ale are mostly water as well. Regular soda brings sugar along with the water, and colas bring some caffeine, so water or diet versions are better everyday choices.
Are sports drinks like Gatorade hydrating?
Yes, but at rest they're no better than water: the sports drink in the 2016 trial scored the same as still water. They earn their place during exercise. The American College of Sports Medicine says drinks with electrolytes and carbohydrates can help more than water alone in some situations, such as long, sweaty sessions, because they replace the sodium you lose in sweat. American College of Sports Medicine position stand, 2007.
For a normal day at a desk, or a short workout, water does the job without the sugar.
Gatorade vs Pedialyte vs coconut water: electrolytes compared →
Is beer hydrating?
Not really, and alcohol is never a good way to hydrate. In the 2016 trial, a lager was no different from water over four hours. A 2017 trial in older men gave them 30 g of alcohol as beer, wine or spirits, or the same volume of the non-alcoholic versions or water. Wine and spirits made them pee more for a short while; beer did not differ from non-alcoholic beer. Polhuis et al., Nutrients, 2017.
So a regular beer won't dry you out, but stronger drinks will a little, and drinking more alcohol is not the answer either way. Hangover? What helps and what doesn't → Non-alcoholic beer hydrates like other mostly-water drinks. Rainu doesn't have an alcohol drink type.
Kombucha, lemon water and flavored water
- Lemon water and other flavored or infused water are water with a little taste. They count fully. Lemon water benefits: what's real →
- Distilled water hydrates like any water, it just has almost no minerals. Can you drink distilled water? →
- Kombucha is fermented tea: mostly water, with a little caffeine and sugar. It counts toward your day like tea.
- Electrolyte drinks and tablets mixed into water count as the water they're mixed into.
What is the most hydrating drink?
If you mean the drink your body holds on to longest after one big glass: skimmed milk, an oral rehydration solution and whole milk topped the 2016 trial. Oral rehydration solutions are made to replace the fluid and salts you lose when you're ill.
Rehydrating after a stomach bug or a hard workout? See how long it takes to rehydrate.
For every day, plain water is still the best choice. It hydrates as well as almost anything else, with no sugar, calories or caffeine, and it's free from the tap.
Does it count toward your daily water intake?
Yes, nearly all of it does. Water guidelines count water from all drinks, not only plain water, and some from food too. EFSA, Dietary Reference Values for water, 2010. In Rainu, every drink counts by its typical water content: water and tea 100%, coffee 99%, juice and soda 89%, milk 88%. A 330 ml can of soda adds about 294 ml of water to your day.
Work out how much you need with the water intake calculator →
Questions
Is seltzer as hydrating as water?
Yes. Sparkling water was no different from still water in a trial that measured how much fluid the body kept. Unsweetened seltzer and club soda are the same: water with bubbles.
Is milk more hydrating than water?
For a few hours after drinking it, yes. Whole and skimmed milk scored 1.50 and 1.58 on the beverage hydration index, where still water is 1.0. Its protein, fat and minerals slow how fast the fluid leaves your body. Water is still the better everyday drink, with no calories.
Is coconut water more hydrating than water?
No. After exercise, coconut water rehydrated about as well as bottled water and a sports drink, and it caused more bloating and stomach upset.
Is Gatorade more hydrating than water?
Not at rest: a sports drink scored the same as still water. During long, sweaty exercise its sodium and carbohydrates can help more than water alone.
Is decaf coffee hydrating?
Yes. It's mostly water with very little caffeine, so it hydrates like water. Even regular coffee does in moderate amounts.
Does tea count as water intake?
Yes. Black tea hydrated like water in a controlled trial, and herbal tea has no caffeine at all. In Rainu, tea counts at 100% of its volume.
Does soda count as water intake?
Yes, it's mostly water and cola hydrated like water in a trial. It also brings sugar (or sweeteners) and sometimes caffeine, so it shouldn't be your main drink. In Rainu, soda counts at 89%.
Do I need to drink only plain water?
No. Most drinks count toward your intake. Plain water is simply the easiest choice with nothing added.
General information, not medical advice. If you have a heart or kidney condition, or your doctor has given you a fluid target or limit, follow their advice. If you drink alcohol, do so in moderation.
